Blog

What 2,250 Games Taught Me About Why ABM Deals Die

By Adam Woozeer · October 19, 2026

Before launching Deploy The Play I wanted to know whether the game was fair. So I built three automated players and made each one play 250 deals at each of the three difficulty tiers. 2,250 games. Same accounts, same buying committees, same deck of tactics.

The numbers came back and they were not really about the game. They were about why enterprise deals die, and they lined up uncomfortably well with every lost ABM account I have sat in a post-mortem for.

THE SETUP

A game of Deploy The Play is one account. A buying committee of four to eight people sits across the table, each with a resistance score. A rival rep works the same deal. You have a limited budget each round and a hand of cards, where every card is a real B2B tactic: an ROI report, a security brief, a reference call, a podcast series, a dinner with the exec.

Push enough people under the resistance line and they become champions. Win the required number of champions before the clock runs out and the deal closes. Simple to describe. Hard to do well, which is the point.

The three players: No plan picks a random affordable card and plays it on a random legal target. Competent clears any gatekeeper first, then always hits the contact closest to converting with the card that does the most damage. ATLAS is the in-game advisor, which scores every legal play on the board and takes the best one. Nothing else differs. No player gets better cards or more budget.

THE RESULTS

Enterprise tier: No plan 20%. Competent 61%. ATLAS 90%.

Contested tier (a stronger rival, faster decay): No plan under 10%. Competent 39%. ATLAS 57%.

Strategic tier (shorter clock, bigger committee): No plan under 10%. Competent 20%. ATLAS 28%.

Read across any row. The cards did not change. The committee did not change. The budget did not change. A player who thinks about sequencing wins three times as often as one who does not, and a player who thinks about it rigorously wins four and a half times as often. In Contested, random play wins fewer than one deal in ten. In the same conditions, the advisor wins more than one in two.

That is the whole ABM argument in one table. Account-based marketing is not a bigger budget or a cleverer tactic. It is the discipline of deciding who to go after, in what order, before you spend anything.

HOW THE DEALS ACTUALLY DIED

I expected the losses to come from the rival. They mostly did not. Almost every lost game ran to the final round. The deal did not get stolen. It timed out.

That matches what I have seen in real pipelines. An enterprise opportunity rarely dies on a specific day. It goes quiet. The champion changes roles. Budget cycles move. The committee never quite reaches the number of yeses it needed, and six months later it is closed-lost with a note that says "no decision".

The no-plan player in Contested finished the average game with less than one champion. Not zero progress. It had spent its whole budget. It had made touches across the entire committee. It just never concentrated enough force on any one person to move them over the line before the clock ran out. If that sounds like a quarter of campaign activity that generated engagement and no pipeline, it should.

THE GATEKEEPER TAX

Some contacts on the board are gatekeepers. While one is in place, the people behind them cannot be influenced at all. There is exactly one card that works on a gatekeeper, and it is not a persuasion card. It is Navigate Politics: finding out who actually controls access and dealing with that first.

The competent player understood this and cleared gatekeepers before spending anything else. The no-plan player played Navigate Politics about as often, by accident, but at random moments, often after it had already burned budget on people it could not reach yet.

Every ABM practitioner has a version of this story. The procurement lead who sat on the deal for a quarter. The IT architect whose sign-off nobody mapped until the security review. The chief of staff who decided which decks the CEO ever saw. The tactic that would have worked on the decision maker was in your hand the whole time. It just could not reach them.

WHY ADVICE BEAT SKILL

The gap I did not expect was between Competent and ATLAS. The competent player is not stupid. It follows a sensible, teachable rule: clear the blocker, then concentrate on whoever is closest to yes. That rule alone triples the win rate over random play.

ATLAS beat it by another thirty points in Enterprise because it looked at the whole board every turn rather than following a rule. It noticed when a card that does less damage on the nearest target does far more on a weaker one two seats over. It noticed when the rival was about to lock a contact and spent a turn defending instead of attacking. It noticed when one more champion this round ends the game and the "best" play was actually the cheapest one that got there.

Rules of thumb get you to competent. Reading the board every single turn is what gets you past it. In a real account, that is the difference between running a playbook and running the account.

THE CAVEATS

These are bots playing a simulation. The no-plan player is literally random, which is harsher than any real rep. Real committees have more than eight people and resistance is not a number. The rival in the game is one rep, not a whole competitive field.

What the simulation gives you is the thing the real world never does: the same deal, replayed hundreds of times, with only one variable changed. You cannot A/B test a $1M opportunity. You can A/B test a model of one, and the model says that sequencing is worth more than any individual tactic in the deck.

PLAY IT YOURSELF

Deploy The Play is free and runs in the browser. Your first deal is a guided one: three contacts, a rival who cannot take it from you, and a few minutes to learn the sequencing instinct. After that the full committee shows up and the clock starts.

Play your first hand. If you want to see the numbers behind the advisor, the full benchmark is published on the ATLAS page.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What is the most common reason ABM deals die?

In the simulation, almost every loss ran out of time rather than being taken by the rival. In practice that is the "no decision" outcome: the committee never reached enough yeses before budgets and people moved on. Spreading effort across every stakeholder instead of concentrating it on the next winnable one is the usual cause.

Who should you target first on a buying committee?

Whoever controls access. If a gatekeeper sits between you and the decision makers, nothing you aim past them lands. Clear the blocker first, then concentrate on the contact closest to converting, then re-read the board every round rather than running the same play.

How was the benchmark run?

Three automated players each played 250 games at three difficulty tiers inside Deploy The Play, with a fresh browser context every 25 games so nothing carried over. The ATLAS and competent figures reproduce the published numbers on the ATLAS page. The random player is noisy by nature, which is why its results are quoted as "under 10%".

Written by Adam Woozeer, a B2B go-to-market strategist and founder of Deploy The Play, the ABM strategy game.
PLAY THE THING THIS IS ABOUT

One enterprise account, a full buying committee, and a rival rep working the same deal. A run takes a few minutes. Free, in your browser, no signup.

PLAY YOUR FIRST HAND →
READ NEXT: WHAT IS ACCOUNT-BASED MARKETING? A CLEAR DEFINITION (NO JARGON) →